Gillette 'We Believe' Advertisement - Creative Analysis
Content analyzed: Gillette - We Believe The Best Men Can Be (P&G, 2019) video advertisement
Content analyzed in this report
Key Findings
- 10/10 production quality and 10/10 narrative coherence — technically flawless execution
- 10/10 uniqueness and 9/10 innovation — meta-commentary on their own past advertising
- HIGH compliance risk — content addresses highly polarized #MeToo social topics
- Strong 9/10 opening hook but weak CTA (6-7/10 clarity, low urgency)
Gillette ‘We Believe’ Advertisement: Creative Analysis
Expert AI review of this social-purpose video ad from Gillette/P&G
Summary
Positioning: Gillette stands for the best a man can be, not just the best shave he can get.
Primary Message: Men have a responsibility to hold each other accountable and set a better example for the next generation.
This cinematic, high-production advertisement represents a bold pivot from functional benefit (shaving close) to emotional/societal benefit (moral character). The creative execution is technically outstanding — 10/10 production quality, a masterful narrative arc, and a 9/10 opening hook that commands attention within the first 3 seconds. However, the strategic boldness carries significant risk: HIGH compliance risk from addressing polarized social topics, and a weak call-to-action that may fail to convert the intense emotional engagement into measurable brand action.
Strengths
What’s working well in this creative:
- Masterful slogan subversion — Subversion of the iconic 30-year slogan ‘The Best a Man Can Get’ to challenge the audience immediately.
- Cinematic production quality — High production value with cinematic transitions between ‘found footage’ and narrative scenes.
- Intense emotional arc — Creates an intense emotional arc, moving from shame/introspection to hope/empowerment.
- Cultural zeitgeist leverage — Leverages cultural zeitgeist (#MeToo, anti-bullying) to position the brand as a moral leader.
- Strong audio hook — Strong audio hook within the first 3 seconds using the recognizable brand jingle melody in a somber key.
Key Themes
Toxic Masculinity · Bullying · Sexual Harassment · Accountability · Fatherhood
Top Recommendations (Preview)
The highest-impact improvements identified:
1. Balance the Negative Opening with Earlier Positive Examples — Priority: HIGH
Impact: Reduce immediate defensive reactions from the core male demographic.
The first 45 seconds are relentlessly negative, which risks alienating the target audience before the ‘redemption’ arc begins.
2. Strengthen the Call to Action — Priority: MEDIUM
Impact: Increase conversion to the campaign website.
The URL ‘TheBestMenCanBe.org’ appears briefly at the end; a clearer on-screen text overlay or verbal call during the final scene would improve traffic.
All Actionable Insights
Balance the Negative Opening with Earlier Positive Examples
| Priority | Complexity | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| HIGH | Moderate | Reduce immediate defensive reactions from the core male demographic. |
The first 45 seconds are relentlessly negative, which risks alienating the target audience before the ‘redemption’ arc begins.
Strengthen the Call to Action
| Priority | Complexity | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| MEDIUM | Simple | Increase conversion to the campaign website. |
The URL ‘TheBestMenCanBe.org’ appears briefly at the end; a clearer on-screen text overlay or verbal call during the final scene would improve traffic.
Distribution & Targeting
Recommended channels and timing for this creative:
Social Media
Times: Evening, Prime Time
High viral potential requires platforms where conversation threads can amplify the message.
TV
Days: Sunday, Monday Times: Prime Time
Disrupts the typical ‘beer and trucks’ ad breaks during sports with a serious message.
Digital Display
Contextual alignment with current events and cultural commentary.
Strengths & Improvements
What’s Working
- Masterful subversion of the iconic 30-year slogan ‘The Best a Man Can Get’ to challenge the audience immediately.
- High production value with cinematic transitions between ‘found footage’ and narrative scenes.
- Creates an intense emotional arc, moving from shame/introspection to hope/empowerment.
- Leverages cultural zeitgeist (#MeToo, anti-bullying) to position the brand as a moral leader.
- Strong audio hook within the first 3 seconds using the recognizable brand jingle melody in a somber key.
Areas to Improve
Balance the Negative Opening with Earlier Positive Examples — HIGH · Moderate
Impact: Reduce immediate defensive reactions from the core male demographic.
The first 45 seconds are relentlessly negative, which risks alienating the target audience before the ‘redemption’ arc begins.
Strengthen the Call to Action — MEDIUM · Simple
Impact: Increase conversion to the campaign website.
The URL ‘TheBestMenCanBe.org’ appears briefly at the end; a clearer on-screen text overlay or verbal call during the final scene would improve traffic.
Detailed Analysis
Pacing & Rhythm
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Pace Score | 7/10 |
| Pace Type | Dynamic |
| Brand Reveal | 0:06 |
Starts chaotic and fast-paced to induce anxiety, slows down significantly for the ‘solution’ phase to convey stability and thoughtfulness.
Visual Quality
| Dimension | Score |
|---|---|
| Camera Work | 9/10 |
| Lighting | 8/10 |
| Color Grading | 9/10 |
| Continuity | 9/10 |
| Production | 10/10 |
Opening Hooks
0:00 — Pattern Interrupt
Introspective mirror shot with subverted slogan audio. Audio of news reports combined with close-up facial expressions.
Effectiveness: 9/10
Narrative Arc
Coherence Score: 10/10
A classic redemption arc: acknowledging past faults (society’s and the brand’s), the turning point of realization, and the commitment to a better future.
| Phase | Timestamp | Description |
|---|---|---|
| The Problem | 0:00 → 0:38 | Montage of bullying, harassment, and ‘boys will be boys’ excuses. (Conflict) |
| The Turning Point | 0:38 → 0:48 | News anchor announces allegations; ‘But something finally changed’. (Setup) |
| The Solution | 0:49 → 2:00 | Men stepping in to stop bad behavior; fathers teaching sons. (Solution) |
| The Future | 2:01 → 2:28 | Focus on the boys watching today who will be men tomorrow. (CTA) |
Brand Presence
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Visibility | 9/10 |
| First Brand Cue | 0:00 |
Recall Hook: The subversion of the famous ‘Best a Man Can Get’ jingle.
Brand Moments:
- 0:06 — Old Gillette commercial playing on TV (High, Logo)
- 2:26 — Final Logo and Slogan (High, Logo)
Emotional Profile
Emotions: Shame → Hope → Responsibility
Emotional Journey:
- 0:10 — Discomfort
- 0:45 — Determination
- 2:10 — Hope
Shifts from a gritty, uncomfortable reflection on reality to an aspirational and polished vision of the future.
Audio Profile
| Element | Value |
|---|---|
| Voiceover Style | Authoritative yet introspective |
| Music Style | Orchestral, shifting from dissonant/tense to major key/uplifting |
| Audio-Visual Alignment | 10/10 |
Sound Design: Use of overlapping news audio creates a sense of overwhelming societal pressure in the intro.
Call to Action
CTA Text: “TheBestMenCanBe.org”
Appears at: 2:22
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Clarity | 7/10 (Detailed Analysis) / 6/10 (Audience Section) |
| Urgency | Low |
| Present | Yes |
Placement Notes: Appears only at the very end as text. Passive CTA.
Friction Points:
- URL requires memorization
- No clickable element (in TV format)
Audience Analysis
Primary Audience
Men 18-50
Secondary Audiences
- Parents of young boys
- Women/Partners
Audience Fit: 8/10
Competitive Position
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Uniqueness | 10/10 |
| Innovation | 9/10 |
| Risk Level | Bold |
Differentiating Elements
- Social commentary instead of product demo
- Focus on internal character rather than external appearance
- Meta-commentary on their own past advertising
Compliance & Risk
Risk Level: HIGH
Flagged Issues
- Brand Safety: Content addresses highly polarized political/social topics (#MeToo), creating significant PR risk.
Cultural Sensitivity Notes
- Depiction of sexual harassment
- Bullying violence
- Political news clips
Cultural Fit & Market Readiness
Regional Market Fit
| Region | Score |
|---|---|
| United States | 10.0/10 |
| United Kingdom | 8.0/10 |
| European Union | 7.0/10 |
| Asia Pacific | 5.0/10 |
Lens Insights
Multi-perspective analysis from specialized viewpoints:
Advertiser Perspective
High viral potential due to controversial nature, but significant risk of negative sentiment and brand boycott. Engagement metrics will be high, but sentiment analysis is critical.
Brand Strategist Perspective
A bold pivot from functional benefit (shaving close) to emotional/societal benefit (moral character). This redefines the brand equity for a modern era but risks alienating legacy customers.
Creative Director Perspective
The ‘breaking through the screen’ visual metaphor (0:09) is a strong creative device representing the disruption of the status quo.
Marketer Perspective
Targeting the ‘conscious consumer’ segment while attempting to retain the mass market. The message-market fit is risky for a commodity product.
Analysis Methodology
This analysis was conducted using Chorus, Navay’s AI-powered research platform. The system evaluates content across multiple dimensions including visual quality, pacing, narrative structure, brand presence, emotional resonance, and audience fit.
Analysis Parameters:
- Content Type: Video
- Duration: 2:28
- Scenes Analyzed: 4 narrative phases
About This Research
This report was generated using Chorus, Navay’s AI-powered research platform, demonstrating how AI can provide comprehensive creative analysis typically requiring multiple specialists.
Want similar insights for your content? Book a demo or explore more research.